Thursday, June 25, 2009

I am a good daughter

Her voice sounds old, worn out.

I was silent on the other end of the line while she spoke as I tried to balance this mother - daughter thing as best I could. The subject now was on how alone she was, how difficult recovery would be because of that and I could not help but to speak, things need to be said, heard. My heart opened up as sure as my mouth did and I began, "You give what you get in relationships…", and she went silent. Was that a double bladed knife I lobbed just then? Is it possible that I do this in the same way she has done all of these years and am I so well trained in this craft that I would not be aware of it until now?

Holding the receiver, I chew on this while she begins to talk again on the other end of the line.

This dance that my mother does with me, her daughter, it can be tiring. I have developed thick skin so as to better shield myself from the words she once threw, but there are still holes in my surface and she is shrewd in her conniving and I want to trust her but it comes slowly. She could get a knife in reach my heart, now open, I silently warn myself but remain the same, as she talks about an out of body experience she has had, my eyes roll and I hold my forehead while my mind is no longer there listening to her.

Finally I ask about the test results of the tumor and find out no malignancy, she tells me the tumor was 25 pounds (which I chalk up to my mothers exaggeration practices) and then she does something that caught me off guard. She mentions that she has called both my siblings much earlier in the day about the results and she knows that I know she did not call me.

She had one son and one daughter and she does not need me…

The words she had cut me with so long ago in childhood find me again, the wound freshly opened now seeping, those words echoed through my head as if it had happened, just now. My fearful and unforgiving mind goes into overdrive for a split second and suddenly all I want to do is hang up the phone and scream and throw things, like a child having a tantrum; Why am I not good enough still?! But I stayed put, took in a deep breath and listened to her talk for a while longer. I reminded myself that this is not about me, this is about her and she is getting old. I said I loved her, hope she felt better, at the end of the conversation and she said it back. We both mean it, I am sure, the only difference is we love in different ways. Just because she does not love me the way I would like her to, does not mean I cannot love her the way I need to.(I owe much thanks to my father for that gem).

Lesson Learned. Maybe it is possible that sometimes you get more than you give, but I want to believe that everything balances out in the end and I am all about balance.

At lunch, I walked on the lake shore in the burning heat a sweaty, smelly mess and strangely I felt cleansed by the sun and the heat and the sweat. Sitting on a cement slab under the sun it is easy to consider all that I have become as the boats bob up and down in the water. Slowly the words that I choose to cover the wound with on my walk back to my office were simply: "I am a good daughter."

27 comments:

Gin said...

I can so relate to this post. Not with my mother, but with my husband. He had told me so many times what a horrible mother and wife I was that I believed him and trudged through life with horrible guilt. When I finally started recovering one day it hit me. I am a good mother and I am a good wife. It is an amazing feeling when that finally hits home isn't it? Beautiful post Cat.

Tall Karen said...

I felt the familiar stab in my heart as I read your words today. But we have learned to forgive...not only our mothers, but ourselves as well. You made me want to be a better daughter today.

Lou said...

Cat,I don't think it always balances out. Maybe it's not supposed to, as some people suffer much more hurt than others.

What you can control is your attitude, and how you want to interpret your life's events. You have expressed some very difficult emotions in a most eloquent way here.

I've come to a similar place with my mother. Accept what it is, because I know I'm a good person.
Let's hug ourselves;)

Ann H. said...

Cat, ditto. Same with a brother and sister. You're much healthier than I am though, when that 'jealousy' or whatever it is rises up, I remind myself how much more my brother and sister have to deal with her and it makes me feel better in a twisted sort of way...

Kristin H. said...

((Cat))

vicariousrising said...

I'm the last to hear in my family too, but I've come to more or less accept it now. The fact that your mother needs to drive home that she's told your siblings is just an indication she does seek your attention. I think you are handling things beautifully in a not so beautiful situation.

And I know exactly what you mean about you and your mom loving each other but having it mean completely different things. Maybe I should send you my third to last chapter of my novel.

Jessie said...

Wow ... what a post. Your words are always so strong. I have no doubt you're a good daughter...
smiles and hugs,

Steve E. said...

((((CAT))))


(Well, Kristin did it...and I've been wanting to do that for a lomg time!)-grin

Employee No. 3699 said...

You are a good daughter, and a good person.

One can never get too many so...

(((Hugs)))

Sierra Wolf said...

*sigh* Mother-daughter relationships. They are so complicated and powerful.
You amaze me with your strength.
Hugs to you Cat.
~Susan

Cindy said...

OK, I'll join in, hugs are contagious.
(((((CAT)))))
You're a bigger person than I am. I'm struggling with my prickly mother. After 50 years of her competition (I'm the opponent) and yes, I'm the oldest child...I have such a wall it's almost impossible for me to even care about her. And I see her often and live 4 houses away. I need some love for her. Working on it.

Bernadine said...

Cat,
I can really relate. My Mom does this to my fabulously giving and kind sister, for no other reason than she's picked her as the whipping child. I'm so inspired by the strength you used to realize-- you ARE a good daughter. You are so full of recovery and I'm lucky to see it.
I agree with everyone else-- ((CAT!))
You are lovely, just as you are.

Syd said...

Cat, there is nothing that seems to gets the old tapes playing in my head than the parental stuff. My parents are no longer around but I know that there was always a feeling that I didn't measure up. I know now that I did. I know that you do too. You are a good daughter and a good person. Period.

Prayer Girl said...

Thanks Cat for the great post.

I hear recovery shouting from your writing.

It's not easy to attain a measure of serenity and balance and very beautiful when I hear it.

I'm sure you touched a lot of hearts and minds with your words.

Prayer Girl

JC said...

I am sorry ...

My Mom and I had an up and down relationship. Towards the end, I just tried to be her friend.

I have ended up having a troubled relationship with my daughter. Only time will heal the wounds that she has caused me.

I am trying to be a sort of Mom to her, when she needs me to.

It's not easy. You may never understand why .. you can only try.

You'll know when it's time to stop ..

BringMeFlowers00 said...

We give such power to others especially family members...what would happen to the word "guilt" if we didn't!

Carol said...

I'm sorry that she is so trying to you. I also worry that I'm repeating patterns that my mother has, I know that I am, I know that is where my grimness comes from and at times I think that I'm worse than she was. What a feeling of defeat. But I know that it is just my sick mind forming these opinions and that I have excellence in other areas. I have my own fingerprint!

Woman in a Window said...

Cat, good for you. It's not easy to give yourself that gift, I'm sure, but you deserve it.

And this, "Just because she does not love me the way I would like her to, does not mean I cannot love her the way I need to." So damned smart!

Vicki in AZ said...

Soo... one could accuse me of choosing a book by its cover, I think your profile picture is adorable and I have seen it around. Here I am, I don't even know anything about you and I was holding my breath waiting for what your mom would say!
You writing is magical and I can't wait to read more.
Yes you are Good Enough!

Shadow said...

of course you're a good daughter. after all, there comes a time in everyone's life, where one has to accept responsibility for oneself. and only for oneself. and that's what you're doing. and that's the right thing to do.

cat said...

Not only a "Good Daughter", but a great, wonderful friend. Thank you for your well meaning words in my time of need. I will pray for you also and hope one day you and your mother will find peace.

Thanks Cat, your a keeper and a great friend.

Annette said...

Truer words were never spoken...you ARE a good daughter, a good woman, a good mother, wife, human being. This is a great post.

Di-Git said...

Oh yes I know this one my mother and I have a very similar dance step. I try to step on the other foot and she grabs me back for more
Detach is what I try
Detach

G-Man said...

I do not believe for one minute that you sweat.

I do believe that you 'glisten'!!

You should have condensed this to 55 words...*hint*

Carry On........G

Ms Hen said...

YES you are a good daughter.. a ideal one.. remember that always.

LceeL said...

Good Daughter? - Better than she deserves, I suspect - but what's more important, is that you are, you most certainly are, a Good Woman.

AlmightyHeidi said...

I read this a week ago and could not comment, I had to process..all I can say is I know how you feel.